I've probably commented on this before

But now, I don't really ship any, they are what, 1-2? And horses aren't well mature ujtill 5-7ish so.... yeah... they still have

STARLEAF FOREVER! STARLEAF FOREVER! STARLEAF FOREVER! (Bangs a drum to go along with the rythm)

EENIE MEENIE MINIE MO, CATCHA LAND HORSE BY ITS TAIL, IF HE HOLLERS LET HIM GO, MY DAM SAID TO CHOOSE THE VERY BEST ONE AND YOU WILL BE IT FOR ALL OF ETERNITY!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (Lands on Starleaf)

YASSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!

Kaylee you and I have the same thoughts about that.

Skyfeather thats never struck me before!! Yeah maybe she did....

IS J.A. SERIOUS????? If she doesn't write about them again she will be ruining her master peice of GUARDIAN HERD!!!!!! *SPOILER ALERT FOR WINDBORN* And plus didn't she take away Star's power on purpose (so that he wouldn't be immortal and could be with morningleaf??)

Is it cause u love bugs and nature? ugh.

Kidding XD If so, so am I :P

my dad calls my brother "Bug-A-Lugs". Dont ask why; im not sure i can answer

lol

My real life nicknames: Emy, Em, Emmy-loo ( the last was created by my dad lol)

XD yay

:D C:

*EMI! There we go C:

XD thanks actually thats me real life nickname. Emi. :P

So true Emy so true.

New Chappy Nickname. Idc :P

Definitely!

That is soooo true!!!

am i getting too deep? Apologies if so

XD okai also EXACTLY!!!!! POOR ECHOFROST 😱😤😓😪 BRACKENTAIL SHOULD'VE DON THE SAME FOR ECHOFROST INSTEAD OF HAD HIS HEART SET ON WINNING MORNINGLEAF OVER. -goes up to Brackentail- Why u so jelly of Star?! Him and Morningleaf are meant to be!! Leave them alone. If you have the heart to save Morningleaf over andover, and to die for her over and over, why didnt you do the same to Echofrost instead of let her be tortured! Granted Rockwing is a ihdhihsgdojojjwsgbtfiswq for killing half of Echofrost's spirit, but you could've always distracted the guards or something as a diversion so she could at least get away!! If you're heart is so comitted to Morningleaf's, why not save Echofrost as well as her?

I love you guys!! Yeah, seriously, why!?!?!?!!!? And I agree with you SO deeply Rainfeathe- no, I should use your real names. I AGREE WITH YOU SO MUCH SOPHIA AND EMILY!!!!!!

Exactly! And why the fact that all the times Brackentail sacrified himself to save MORNINGLEAF and didnt do the same to poor Echofrost? :(

THATS THE RIGHT IDEA GUYS!!!!!!!! STARLEAF STARLEAF STARLEAF STARLEAF STARLEAF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

p.s. Woah Rainfeather you went DEEP. Also you hold a good point. If I found out my worst enemy from my childhood wanted my forgiveness just to win the heart of my best friend, I would be equally as furious as a normal person would. But Star isnt normal; he's too trusting. Brackentail The Betrayer was meant to be. I knew that if Star forgave Brackentail when I was reading Stormbound, Brackentail would find another way to kill him. Maybe not in the same way as before, in the Canyon Run; maby not physically. And he did. He killed Star's spirit multiple times by giving out hints of jealousy and hinting that Morningleaf was his. Granted he probably didn't mean to, but when he was a foal, he shouldn't have tried to kill Star. He thought that if Star was dead and Brackentail stepped in to "save" Morningleaf of her misery, she'd forget all about Star. But honestly, if Star HAD died in the race, Morningleaf would just be MORE angry with him, not less.

GO STARLEAF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

INDEED <:

YEEEESSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

STARLEAF SHALL LIVE FOREVER

STARLEAF!!! *STARTS CHANTING* STARLEAF STARLEAF STARLEAF STARLEAF

BRACKENLEAF

jasperpony

Riverbreeze123

jgracew120 (?)

(trying to remember the others.)

STARLEAF

Rainfeather

CassTucher1

Starbrook1705

jgracew120 (?)

Ashflame

Echomoon

Love Those Cats

(sorry, there are so many starleaf shipers I forgot some of you.)

I love ya Rainfeather, I really do.

Starfire: Brackentail shouldn't have been jeolous or killed him. When Brackentail was captured, Morningleaf was beaten, it wasnt his fault but he shouldn't have listened to Rockwing, he should have fought with his life to protect her, just like star would. And Rockwing only said if you threaten to bargain he will kill her. Not fighting back. I think of him at that point a coward. And in the rest of the books he would fight his life for MORNINGLEAF. Stormbound: We can't blame Star for forgiving Brackentail. Imagine seeing a beaten body, broken wing, and sad, dead, pleading eyes. Plus the fact that it reminded him of himself. It was right to do this. But I wish he hadn't. He hadnt shown thanks. He didnt care. There was proove when he said '"I wouldn't do that morningleaf." he looked directly at morningleaf' He should be focusing on repaying Star. Not trying to win Morningleaf over. In this series Brackentail hadnt done TO much disturbance. Landfall: When Brackentail went with Morningleaf even when she DIDNT give permission he saved her life multiple times. Why couldn't he save Echofrost's? When they set off he had shown multiple signs of jeolousy deep within him such as the quotes, "I know, you just want star." and "I am lost." When Brackentail went on there adventure my only favorite part was a hint that Morningleaf loved star and not Morningleaf, "You are the bravest pegasi I know, next to Star."When they came back from the journey, yes star was jelly, but I couldn't blame him. Imagine how would you feel. Forgiving your enemy that tried to kill you just to find out that he just wanted to win back Morningleaf. Though, he handled his slight jeolousy better than Brackentail did, Brackentail tried to to kill him very much unlike Star. Windborn: By far this show how the two grown ever so close. Star's jeolusy grew but he still adored the stallion in contrast to Brackentail back then. I have less to speak about this. Though it conforted me at the quote. "Though Morningleaf have been more alive with him. And Star didnt think he was wrong." My main reason why I like Starleaf is because...1. They are born on the same day.2. Star is bigger and handsomer than Brackentail.3. The foal of Starleaf would result in a black foal, which could be a swell continuation of TGH4. They have been closer for a longer time.5. Brackentail, as I said, still has signs of jeolousy.6. Brackentail saved MORNINGLEAF'S LIFE COUNTLESS TIME RISKING HIS OWN LIFE AND HE DIDNT DO THE SAME TO POOR ECHOFROST!7. Starleaf really sounds better than Brackenleaf XD

These all the reasons why I hate Brackenleaf and love Starleaf.

Sure! C:

Wanna O.C. Chat?

O: ELLO! XD

Hi!

Rainfeather: Snap.. now I am :C

You still on Rainfeather?

I just noticed. We have a Team Starleaf, A Team Brackenleaf, and A Anti-Brackential squad. AH THE TEAMS OF SHIPS ARE GROWING C:

STARLEAF 4 EVAH #TEAMSTARLEAF

STARLEAF FOREVER.

You mean TWO YEARLINGS!! 😰😰

xD

Lol

She (literally) said:

You're right, this auestion is asked by most fans. But incase I decide to write about them again, I wont spoil it

😑😑😑😑 the cruelty...

(ASHFOIGHT YOU DO REALISE PEEPS CAN DIE OF SUSPENSE!?!?!? YOU KILLED AN INNOCENT YEARLING TODAY) XD

Omg I'm so dumb....she didn't say 🤣

Whelp...nvm ten....

Wait Echo what did Jennifer say?

Anyway, I'm gonna go scream and celebrate in the dark corner of the room😂

By your reaction I'm gonna say Brackenleaf

Thank u for delivering hope, Cass. THANKU -fliis up to Morningleaf- so, who do you love as a mate? Star or Brackentail?

Morningleaf: -flinches- WTH get away from meh you creppy weirdo!!!

Me: -ears droop- i get that a lot....

I asked her and she said that the characters were to young and traumatized to think about "dating" so I still have hope!!!!

couldnt have said it better myself

... that moment when u finally see the light...

And it burns your eyes 😤